The Gold Pocket Watch

The Gold Pocket Watch

This is part of my mass deletion for the reviews I have written as I am no longer proud of them of what I have wrote and I feel uncomfortable leaving them up for everyone to see.

The quick brown Duke jumps over the lazy fox dog creature.

fishingbrogl · 21
There's got to be treacheries that trigger during (begin/end) the investigation phase and discard at the end of the round, though I can't put my finger on it. Still not worth for everybody to lose all actions, I'd argue. — AlderSign · 469
Oh, no, what I meant for this is that it's directly sabatoging your team. I don't think there is ever a case in which you want to skip the investigation phase in a multiplayer game. — fishingbrogl · 21
I got that - good card for the pvp version of the game :D — AlderSign · 469

Faustian Bargain

Faustian Bargain

This is part of my mass deletion for the reviews I have written as I am no longer proud of them of what I have wrote and I feel uncomfortable leaving them up for everyone to see.

The quick brown Duke jumps over the lazy fox dog creature.

fishingbrogl · 21

Another Day, Another Dollar

Another Day, Another Dollar

This is part of my mass deletion for the reviews I have written as I am no longer proud of them of what I have wrote and I feel uncomfortable leaving them up for everyone to see.

The quick brown Duke jumps over the lazy fox dog creature.

fishingbrogl · 21

Overzealous

Overzealous

This is part of my mass deletion for the reviews I have written as I am no longer proud of them of what I have wrote and I feel uncomfortable leaving them up for everyone to see.

The quick brown Duke jumps over the lazy fox dog creature.

fishingbrogl · 21
For those interested in looking up the Call of Cthulhu LCG cards for yourselves it's going to be difficult to do so without navigating this Google Drive folder. There are plenty more cards that share art that I didn't cover here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1dqooB5JZNNyoNxs__R2TmBYrqXJ8Z9kA?usp=drive_link — fishingbrogl · 21
I am not sure why you Indebted as a "brutal" weakness. In my opinion it's a nothing burger most of the time. Yes losing 2 resources at the start is far more brutal than later and it is guranteed to hit you no matter what, but even if you need to gather resources twice, countering that weakness is the same as any "2 action to remove" weaknesses, it's extremely predictable and can't randomly screw you over mid scenario like Amnesia, Paranoia or Overzealous can. — HeroesOfTomorrow · 95
I agree with pretty much the whole review except for the point raised above. Indebted is, to me, one of the most mild weaknesses out there. — Eudaimonea · 9
Sorry, I'm not sure why I included it. it seemed bad to me at first? I don't know anymore. — fishingbrogl · 21
I could just edit the review if it makes sense to do so — fishingbrogl · 21
*why you listed — HeroesOfTomorrow · 95
@fishingbrogl I mean, it's fine. It's a review, a matter of opinion, which inevitably is different compared to the opinion of other people; it's just that me and Eudaimonea don't consider Indebted that bad. There are some nasty aspects to it, like the fact draining your starting resources is really bad compared to taking away later on, or that it is guranteed to hit you no matter what, while other weaknesses you have a chance of not drawning. But it's still something that you can just counter with any economy card, even something as simple as Emergency Cache, so it's not that bad imo. But at the end of the day, it's your call — HeroesOfTomorrow · 95
I do agree though that the core campaign has some really headscratching balance choices. For something that is supposed to be an entry point for new players, it just kicks them nice and hard with some crippling weaknesses and one of the nastiest damage treacheries in the game, in the form of "Fire!". I am really afraid stuff like that can cheap shots like scenario one second act (oh, you defeated the boss? Good job idiot, he fully heals), is just gonna alienate newcommers. — HeroesOfTomorrow · 95
*... stuff like that and cheap shots... — HeroesOfTomorrow · 95
On a different topic, I wish we could use || for spoilers and such. — fishingbrogl · 21
Maybe another character since people started using "||" for the parallel investigators :/ I wanted to add that Indebted does not waste your draw and thins your deck, which are another 2 upsides. — AlderSign · 469
Also, unlike other "2 actions to remove" weakness, you can take the two actions to gather resources separately to "remove" indebted, which gives you more flexibility to catch up. — HeroesOfTomorrow · 95
Plus: Regaining those 2 resources only costs 2 actions in the worst case. Such a good card, wish I could take it every time. — AlderSign · 469

Ultimate Sacrifice

Ultimate Sacrifice

This is part of my mass deletion for the reviews I have written as I am no longer proud of them of what I have wrote and I feel uncomfortable leaving them up for everyone to see.

The quick brown Duke jumps over the lazy fox dog creature.

fishingbrogl · 21
What is happening to this samurai in this Legend of the Five Rings art piece that they’re trying to pass off as an Arkham Horror card now that the game it was commissioned for is bankrupt? — Eudaimonea · 9
There's no way. What card is the art repurposed from? — fishingbrogl · 21
I know it's probably a joke, but Carolyn can't get Sledgehammer upgraded — HeroesOfTomorrow · 95
@fishingbrick, I’m being facetious. A directly stated version of my comment would be, “While I agree the art is attractive and that the card might create big, dramatic moments, ithe art does not suggest 1920s Arkham, nor a horror game. In fact, the character appears to me to be to be dressed in samurai garb and the scene appears most evocative of a figure receiving the light of Amaterasu. In actuality, I don’t know why or for whom this art was originally made, but I’d call it a cool piece for a different game. — Eudaimonea · 9