Had one game with William Yorick and baseball bat. I don't quite see why it is a good fit at all. An auto fail leave the player encountered yet unequipped. Two hand slots means there's no backup weapon. Yorick can only retrieve assets after a defeat. Any two health enemy, at level difficult, could be hard to defeat at difficult level.

I Immediately swapped to .45 Thompson, and eventually went for old hunting riffle, by which time the risk can be managed with eucatastrophe and will to survive. and most importantly old hunting riffle, while jammed, is a valid candidate of act of desperation, which can loop with Yorick's elder sign ability and resourceful.

I can't think of a single use for this card. Seriously it's just +1 damage and only +2 will. It's exceptional so it not only is more expensive than other more useful cards but also is so bad because you need to have something in place to handle the doom that gets placed on it. If it did not take up an arcane slot I could maybe see a use for it or if it was at the very least a fast action and cost nothing to play but it's just awful. If you are doing some kind of challenge run I guess I could see some use because of how bad it is or maybe a doom build but it's just so awful. I think that if it was a level 0 card it could work maybe but seriously in a mystic deck? You gotta be kidding me.

In addition to helping you evade in an emergency, healing 2 horror "from among cards you control" has potential synergy with other cards you might be running, such as Cloak of Resonance, Field Agent, Hunter's Armor, or Aquinnah.

Being able to hit for 3 damage gets this over several key HP breakpoints in Chapter 2 content. And if you find yourself unable to deploy this as an attack yourself, having to commit to a primary fighter is a nice consolation.

As a seeker, you'll often have access to the clues needed to get the bonus damage. We'll have to see how future Chapter 2 campaigns shake out, but in just the core, there are a startling number of enemies that have 3+ health even in the very first scenario, so there will be a lot of situations where this does not serve the job of "get the enemy off of me, permanently." Could still be worth playing, particularly if you have concerns about the rest of your party's ability to fight through an Elite enemy - being able to have your add in 2 damage will make it a lot easier for your fighters to defeat an enemy with 5 HP.